Ruth Gipps (1921–1999)

Ruth Gipps (1921–1999)

Author’s Note: For several decades beginning as early as 1908, the PNEU assigned a composer each term for music appreciation. With three terms per year, this provided ample space for a great variety of music to be explored, from early composers such as Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina (1525–1594) to then-living composers such as Ralph Vaughan Williams (1872–1958). Each term a Parents’ Review article would announce the term’s music with biographical information on the composer and a list of compositions to be heard and studied.

Modern Charlotte Mason educators can still benefit from these vintage articles and music selections. The music of the great composers still speaks to us today. However, the story of music did not end with the passing of Ralph Vaughan Williams or the demise of the PNEU. Gifted musicians emerged in the 20th century and continue to emerge today. To encourage the community to embrace the music of more recent composers, I offer this original piece in the tradition of Ella Glover, Cedric Glover, and The Term’s Music.

Ruth Gipps was born in 1921 in Bexhill-on-Sea, England. Like many composers, she was born into a musical family. Her mother, Hélène Gipps, was from Switzerland and ran her own music school. Her father, Bryan Gipps, was an English amateur violinist. The parents planned to have Ruth begin piano lessons on her fifth birthday.

However, at the age of four, after listening to her mother give a lesson on Grieg’s Waltz in A Minor, Opus 12, [Ruth] went to the piano and played the first ten bars perfectly. It was clear that formal tuition could not be delayed.[1]

So it was that as a five-year-old she was not beginning piano lessons, but rather giving her first concert. Yet, even at this very young age, she had a deep sense of calling. She later recalled:

I had of course known all along that playing the piano was my job; the first concert merely confirmed it. But I also knew without a shadow of a doubt, although I had not yet written anything, that I was a composer. Not that I wanted to be a composer — that I was one.[2]

But although she “knew” she would become a composer (or rather, that she “was” a composer), she realized that she had to be a musician first. This meant continuing to develop her skill on the piano, and then going on to learn about other musical instruments.

A major milestone was performing her first piano concerto with a full orchestra. This happened in 1932 when she was eleven years old. She played so well that she was soon invited to perform the Haydn D Major Piano Concerto and the Saint-Saëns Piano Concerto in G Minor for multiple audiences in multiple cities. A reviewer at the time wrote:

It was an amazingly competent performance of splendidly sustained playing and was marked by a maturity of execution that was astonishing in such a young person. She put any amount of personality into her playing and it is in this respect that Ruth displays commanding superiority over the merely clever child pianist who works up some particular piece for public performance and goes through with it in quite a mechanical way. For Ruth, music has meaning which she proceeds to express with intelligence and all the more easily and capably because she has been so well grounded in the technique of her art.[3]

But despite these early successes as a performer, Gipps still saw this only has her “job.” Her true calling was to be a composer, and she had a lot to learn before she could begin using her gifts to produce major works of art.

One thing she had to gain was familiarity with all the instruments of the orchestra. If she was going to compose symphonies, she would have to know the strengths, limitations, and ranges of each instrument. How would she do this? Ever inventive, she leveraged her skill at the piano. She offered free piano accompaniment to performers of other instruments. (While we can’t be certain that her motivation was to learn about these other instruments, it seems likely based on the pattern she followed for these accompaniments.)

Eventually she reached a point in her piano playing that to continue in her career she would have to become a virtuoso and full-time performer. But this was just not the path for her. While she deeply loved classical music, ultimately she did not want to merely be interpreting the music of other composers. She wanted to be writing her own. She could not yet make a career from composing, however, so she began to specialize in oboe. This would allow her to earn money playing in orchestras while still affording time to study and learn.

When World War II broke out, thousands of young men left their normal occupations to serve in the British military. This left a vacuum for women to fill. Suddenly Ruth Gipps had a much greater range of musical opportunities. At this time, her calling, training, and gifting came together as she wrote her first large-scale orchestral work. Entitled Knight in Armour, it was completed in 1940 and performed before “a packed hall on the last night of the 1942 Promenade Concerts by the BBC Symphony Orchestra.”[4] She was only 21 years old. What an early fulfillment of her childhood dream to have her own work performed at such a prestigious event.

While the war brought opportunity for female musicians such as Gipps, it also brought separation and anxiety. Gipps married clarinetist Robert Baker in March 1942. Almost immediately after the wedding, Robert went to the field to serve in the war. So Gipps was left behind on the home front with a complex range of emotions. She was lonely but busy. She was doing the work she dreamed of doing, but her husband was far away and in danger.

At the close of the war, a competition was held for composers to write pieces in celebration of the end of the war. Gipps took this occasion to write her second symphony. Towards the end of her life, she revealed that the symphony was actually autobiographical:

Gipps disclosed that she had conceived the work in three sections, intended respectively to represent her life before the outbreak of war (a young woman at the start of her creative life in every sense); the outbreak of war and its consequences (a woman now in love but separated from her husband: fear and isolation amid the continuity of everyday life); and Robert’s homecoming, accompanied by a return to normality with high hopes for the future (the bringing together of all the strands of life, the prospect of children and a career).[5]

Musicologist Jill Halstead points convincingly to the historical importance of this symphony. In the Western tradition, it had always been understood that music followed the gestures of conflict and resolution. Gipps as a composer was very respectful of this tradition; however, as a woman on the home front of the war, her experience did not map onto this template handed down from generations of great male composers. Her “symphony in one movement” departs from tradition and uses classical forms to tell the story of a person (herself) who remained the same person as the world changed around her. A significant element of the symphony symbolizes when the troops (including her husband) left for the field:

In 1946 one Birmingham critic observed that this section reminded him of the interruptions suffered at the Town Hall as local bands passed by. That the soldiers are in fact moving past, and ultimately away, from the listener is highly symbolic, and is recreated using a palindromic structure. Beginning with the solo drum it develops towards a robust culmination using the full orchestra (bar 236) before going into reverse, the instruments dropping out in the opposite order they entered… As the soldiers move away into the distance (from bar 270 onwards), the onlookers are left to ponder the prospect of life without them, possibly forever.[6]

Although this symphony has been one of Gipps’s most widely performed pieces, it did not win the competition.[7] Presumably the judges were looking for a more traditional celebration of victory, not the deeply personal account of a woman who was left behind.

While Ruth Gipps departed from some musical traditions, she retained a strong commitment to what is called tonal music. Meanwhile composers all around her were adopting the new, modern atonal style. This became the dominant music form, and demand for Gipps’s beautiful, romantic music suddenly subsided. Nevertheless, she continued to grow as a composer, and her masterpieces — her third, fourth, and fifth symphonies — were published with little fanfare and were virtually ignored. But Gipps would not and could not abandon her principles to please the critics and the experts. In 1974 she wrote and published a controversial and startling “Personal Credo” in which she stated:

CREDO — According to the dictionary, ‘I believe’ — but surely that translation will not serve now that the word ‘belief’ has come to imply a doubt. Rather, ‘I know…’, ‘I am sure of…’.

In a period of time when very few people are sure of anything whatever, I wonder if it is a duty for those of us who know a few basics to say so clearly. It is curiously distasteful to state one’s innermost convictions publicly, and no doubt there are some who will distrust any personal certainty as subjective and impossible to prove. Yet it is a simple truth that we do not need to prove the things of which we are sure. None of us can prove that he is in love, or that he has had a mystical experience; nobody can explain why the B Minor Mass and the Brahms symphonies are great music; nobody needs to.
…
CREDO IN UNUM DEUM [I believe in one God]. Also, I know that from that one God comes music and all musical gifts. Some of us were composers from the beginning of our lives; we had no choice in the matter, only a life-long duty to make the most of a given talent. This talent may be large or small, but without it a person is not a composer.
…
Since it happens that I am a composer, I have put music before everything else all my life — showing a scale of values that perhaps … is lacking in humanity, but that is inevitable and right for me — and since I have had experience of inspiration, i.e. of hearing music and taking it down as if from a dictation, I have an absolute certainty about it. What I am about to write is not a mere matter of opinion, it is the truth.

I believe no human being has ever created anything. The most that a composer can do is to present to other people, in comprehensible form, music that already existed. Bach wrote ‘S.D.G.’ [Soli Deo gloria, “Glory to God alone”] at the end of works. None of his music was a product of the cleverness of J. S. Bach.
…
The corollary of the truth that all real music comes from inspiration is that all so-called music written without inspiration is not music at all, and the people who write it are not composers. Ranging from the super-intellectual to the wildest and woolliest lunatic fringe, we have for years been given performances of worthless nonsense, while real composers have been labelled backward-looking, unenterprising, or ‘unwilling to experiment’… ‘Pop’ is no joke. It is a commercial product with the sole purpose of making money and, where good music uplifts, ‘pop’ debases. It was no coincidence that a particular organisation promoting both avant-garde and ‘pop’ was directed by a nihilist. It is time some of us came into the open and said what we know to be true — that, quite apart from the actual physical deafness it is causing, amplified ‘pop’ is evil and injures those who participate in it.
…
We all have our own scales of value, our own ideals to which we cannot afford to be false. For myself, I would sooner die than produce an item of ‘pop’ or set down an example of so-called ‘serial music’. Am I right in thinking that every real composer feels the same? — and that those who do not are not composers?[8]

This manifesto also indicted leading composers of her time by name including Igor Stravinsky and Arnold Schoenberg, further isolating her and restricting her opportunities. As she moved into retirement, she continued to compose beautiful and wonderful pieces, but only few heard her music.

Ruth Gipps died in 1999, but her genius has only recently been widely recognized. From 2018 to 2022, conductor Rumon Gamba led the BBC National Orchestra of Wales and the BBC Philharmonic to produce four CDs of Ruth Gipps’s orchestral works on the Chandos label. Gamba’s work has made Gipps’s greatest music now finally available to all the world. The series include all five symphonies as well as several other important pieces, some composed as recently as 1988.

The music for this term includes several of her symphonies, as well as some of her ensemble pieces.

Symphony No. 2 (in One Movement), Opus 30, composed in 1945, tells the story of a young newlywed experiencing change as a world plunges into and out of war. The Tempo di marcia contains the unforgettable dramatization of marching troops passing by, and the Allegro ends the work with a theme of beautiful optimism.

Symphony No. 3, Opus 57, composed in 1965, shows Gipps’s greater maturity as a composer. Notable in this piece is the fluidity of chords and rhythm. While her music is without doubt tonal and beautiful to listen to, it is by no means constrained by traditional classical forms. It is “perhaps the most consciously neo-Romantic” of Gipps’s symphonies.[9]

Symphony No. 4, Opus 61, composed in 1972, is perhaps Gipps’s most musically profound piece. Its opening movement “is a tense and murky affair,”[10] and the symphony as a whole has “a more dissonant use of tonality and a general terseness of tone that is a world away from Gipps’s usual Romantic optimism.”[11] It is my personal favorite of the five symphonies.

Symphony No. 5, Opus 64, composed in 1982, is notable for its unusual final movement, which is a Missa Brevis for orchestra. This abbreviated Mass has no words, but the original programme note specifies which bars refer to which portion of the liturgy, such as Kyrie Eleison, Gloria in Excelsis Deo, and Credo in Unum Deum.

Oboe Concerto in D Minor, Opus 20, composed in 1941 when she was only 20, is especially interesting because of Gipps’s own experience as a professional oboist. “A dark and stormy theme opens the piece, with a foreboding ostinato (persistent motif) in conflict with the lyrical solo oboe… The second movement is a wistful dialogue between oboe, clarinet, and solo violin, accompanied by strings. The pastoral third movement begins with the oboe plummeting into a sprightly jig. The energy shifts to a quasi-improvisational oboe interlude accompanied by a drone in the winds reminiscent of a Scottish reel. The oboe closes out the movement with a fiery cadenza and a return to spinning, dancing, and joy.”[12]

Leviathan, Opus 59, composed in 1969, is a short, beautiful piece that is unusual in that it features the double bassoon (or contrabassoon) as the solo instrument, accompanied by a chamber orchestra. Several of Gipps’s pieces were about animals; apparently the very low pitches of the double bassoon represent the leviathan of Job 41. This piece “demonstrates Gipps’s tremendous ability to write for wind instruments as well as her skills as an orchestrator, allowing the solo line to dominate despite its unusual tessitura.”[13]

Song for Orchestra, Opus 33, composed in 1948, is “a short tone poem for orchestra.” The piece opens with solo oboe. As the music continues, “Gipps’ colourful lyricism washes over the orchestra as the sweetness of the composer’s style takes hold.” After a “dramatic middle section,” the piece closes as it began, with solo oboe.[14]

Sea-weed Song, Opus 12c, composed in 1940, is an example of works by Gipps inspired by “everyday, often unregarded aspects of the English landscape.” Gipps had a “passion for ‘a simpler way of life’, close to nature,” which “provided the source for some of her more unusual musical preoccupations.”[15]

Ambarvalia for small orchestra, Opus 70, composed in 1988, was dedicated to fellow composer Adrian Cruft, who died on February 20, 1987. This is the first piece I ever heard by Ruth Gipps, and it prompted me to learn more about this composer and her music.

The Lady of the Lambs, Opus 79, composed in 1992, is the second-to-last piece in Gipps’s oeuvre. It is a song with wind accompaniment which sets the words of a poem to music. The poem “The Lady of the Lambs,” written by Alice Meynell (1847–1922), comes to life in the soprano’s voice:

She walks — the lady of my delight —

A shepherdess of sheep.

Her flocks are thoughts. She keeps them white;

She guards them from the steep.

She feeds them on the fragrant height,

And folds them in for sleep.

She roams maternal hills and bright,

Dark valleys safe and deep.

Her dreams are innocent at night;

The chastest stars may peep.

She walks — the lady of my delight —

A shepherdess of sheep.

She holds her little thoughts in sight,

Though gay they run and leap.

She is so circumspect and right;

She has her soul to keep.

She walks — the lady of my delight —

A shepherdess of sheep.

To learn more about the life and music of Ruth Gipps, I recommend Ruth Gipps: Anti-Modernism, Nationalism and Difference in English Music, by Jill Halstead, first published in 2006 by Ashgate Publishing, and issued in paperback in 2016 by Routledge.

Endnotes

[1] Halstead, Jill. (2016). Ruth Gipps: Anti-Modernism, Nationalism and Difference in English Music (New York: Routledge), p. 4. (Original work published 2006 by Ashgate Publishing.)

[2] Gipps, Ruth. Unpublished biography. Quoted in Halstead, op. cit., p. 5.

[3] “Child Pianist,” Bexhill-on-Sea Observer, 1933. Quoted in Halstead, op. cit., pp. 7–8.

[4] Halstead, op. cit., p. 20.

[5] Ibid., p. 153.

[6] Ibid., pp. 154–155.

[7] Ibid., p. 153.

[8] Gipps, Ruth. (1975). “A Personal Credo,” Composer.

[9] Halstead, op. cit., p. 88.

[10] Ibid., p. 92.

[11] Ibid.

[12] The Broadway Bach Ensemble, “Concerto for Oboe and Orchestra.”

[13] wfmt , “new releases.”

[14] Alex Burns, “Ruth Gipps: Song for Orchestra,” 2021.

[15] Halstead, op. cit., p. 105.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *